
I can’t believe I’ve worked in this industry for more than 10 years already. It’s astonishing how many changes there have been, and how many influencers have dropped off along the way. Many creators stopped posting regularly because the demands of constant content creation were simply too much while others have seen their careers skyrocket, as they jumped on every trend and platform. It’s been eye-opening to say the least. Here are some takeaways, and some unfortunate downsides, to a career in influencer marketing.
***
Influencer marketing is among one of the hottest developments in the advertising space, and for good reason. Taking the time to sponsor those who have earned an online following can help you appeal to a much more specific niche, while also achieving the authoritative stature you’re looking for in the eyes of their followers. For example, if a fishing rod brand sponsors an expert YouTube fisherman with hundreds of thousands of subscribers, that brand may achieve sales as a result of that funnel.
However, in the interest of fairness, it’s also wise to consider some of the downsides of influencer marketing. That’s not to dismiss the highly effective practice entirely, but with any marketing push, there are pros and cons to consider. This way, you can cover some of the blind spots with other marketing outreach, like SEO, to cover all your bases.
In this post, we’ll explore some of the downsides of influencer marketing so you’re more able to counteract them in the future:
Niche Online Audiences Are Just That
Online influencers tend to attract very specific types of followers. For example, a beauty YouTuber might reach thousands of makeup enthusiasts, but these viewers probably share similar interests, ages, and sometimes even geographic locations. While this targeting seems perfect to begin with, it can limit your reach, because most businesses need a diverse customer base to grow properly.
Relying too heavily on influencer marketing might connect you deeply with one segment while completely missing others. The fishing rod company example above would probably reach serious fishing enthusiasts, but casual weekend fishers might never see the content, for instance.
The echo chamber effect of social media platforms makes this even more likely. Algorithms show content to people who already enjoy similar topics, so breaking out to reach new potential customers can sometimes be more difficult. This might not alter your approach, but it’s something to be aware of in the interest of covering your bases. And of course, sometimes a niche audience is exactly what you need, which is why using specific marketing experts for your sector can be the best option–it depends on your requirements, so knowing what they are in advance is crucial.
Purchases/Traffic May Not Always Convert To Retail Spaces
Influencers tend to exist online, which doesn’t always guarantee foot traffic to physical locations. An influencer might drive thousands of people to your company’s website or online store, but that same audience might not make the leap to visit your tangible shop, unless it’s an event space they’re reviewing and recommending people go to.
As such, a good counterbalance could involve having in-store exclusives that work alongside your online promotions, encouraging people to make the trip. For example, a local coffee shop might partner with a food influencer who showcases their drinks online, but mentions a special in-store menu item available only to customers who visit. A poster printer could offer online discounts with influencer codes for anyone who walks in off the street, so you cover most of the bases and don’t just offer this to people on your social media platform.
You Can’t Control The Future Branding Or Reputation Of Influencers
Influencers have brands that are totally independent of your firm, even if you can encourage them to follow your script when advertising your product, and even if they’re a predictable partner for years. And of course, influencers are human, and they can easily change opinions, make mistakes, and sometimes become connected to controversies outside of your control.
Some businesses discover this the hard way, as many companies have had to pull ties with celebrities in an embarrassing fashion. You can probably think of a few off the top of your head. Note that this is a possibility with everyone, no matter how stable or family friendly they may seem.
This is also true with the nature of politics these days. Influencers are of course entitled to share their opinions, but there can be a good amount of blowback to that, especially if they speak on contentious issues. Or, if you’re not careful, someone might find a history of terrible online posts and your audience might question why you didn’t check in advance (be sure to do this!).
Unfortunately, this is something you have to stay on guard for. You do have some recourse. For example, long-term contracts with influencers should include moral clauses that allow you to distance your brand if necessary to do so. Of course, avoiding over reliance on any single personality is wise too, because it helps to limit your marketing strategy from collapsing if one relationship goes wrong (think a few smaller influencers than one large one).
It’s Easy To Silo Your Online Image
Influencer marketing can accidentally create separate brand identities that don’t connect well with your overall marketing strategy. The version of your company presented by a YouTube creator might feel completely different from your Facebook ads or in store experience, because after all, your influencer might have a contract and a script, but they don’t necessarily have training or even a thorough understanding of your brand.
Remember that not all influencers will have business acumen or marketing know-how. For example, if an influencer is known for cursing and that’s associated with a brand you’re trying to keep family-friendly, that can be an issue.
Keeping messaging consistent across all channels is something you’ll have to manage, and that becomes more complex the more influencers you bring in. Their unique voice and presentation style will reflects on you, for better or worse.
With this advice, we hope you can get the best out of influencer marketing. Like any pursuit in the advertising space, there is risk and the chance for your approach to not pan out. But overall, if you focus on a mindful and attentive campaign with people appropriate to your brand, it’s a good pursuit to invest in.
Photo by Liza Summer.
Great information!